Outsourcing, contract terms, outsourced IT

Key contract terms to negotiate in an outsourced IT Project

Dr. Brendan O'Brien

When negotiating a contract with an outsourced IT firm, it's crucial to focus on terms that protect your interests, ensure high-quality work, and maintain control over the project .

What are some critical beneficial contract terms to negotiate for a Startup requiring outsourced IT services?

  1. A clear scope of work: Ensure that the scope of work is clearly defined, outlining the services to be provided, project deliverables, and the responsibilities of both parties.
  2. Performance metrics and service levels: Establish measurable performance indicators (KPIs) and minimum service levels to assess service quality. Incorporate incentives for exceeding these levels and penalties for failing to meet them.
  3. Change management: Include provisions for handling changes in project scope or requirements. Specify how these changes will be documented, approved, and billed to ensure transparency and minimize disputes.
  4. Data security and privacy: Clearly outline the provider's obligations to protect sensitive data and maintain compliance with relevant data protection regulations. Include provisions for regular audits, data breach notifications, and liability for data breaches.
  5. Intellectual property rights: Specify ownership and licensing terms for any intellectual property developed during the project to prevent potential disputes and protect your startup's proprietary assets.
  6. Confidentiality: Include confidentiality clauses to safeguard sensitive business information shared with the outsourced IT team. Payment terms and caps: Clearly outline payment terms, including fees, payment schedules, and any additional charges for out-of-scope work. Consider negotiating caps on the total cost, particularly in time-and-materials contracts, to mitigate the risk of cost overruns.
  7. Termination clauses: Establish conditions for contract termination, including any notice periods, potential liabilities, and the return of assets or intellectual property.
  8. Warranty and maintenance: Negotiate warranty terms that cover any defects in the work and specify the duration of post-project support, maintenance, or bug fixing. Dispute resolution: Detail the processes for resolving disputes, such as mediation or arbitration, to facilitate amicable solutions.
  9. Flexibility and scalability: Include provisions for adjusting the scope of services as your startup grows or its needs evolve, allowing for adding or removing services as necessary.

By negotiating these key contract terms, you can protect your startup's interests, ensure high-quality work, and maintain control over your project while fostering a successful and mutually beneficial outsourcing partnership.

What are the differentiating points of a good or bad contractual or service level agreement SLA? What makes for a very good vs a lazy service level agreement SLA?

A Service Level Agreement is a binding contract between an outsourced IT service provider and a client. It outlines the expected level of service, performance metrics, and remedies in case the provider fails to meet the agreed-upon standards.

Here are some differentiating points between a good and bad SLA, as well as what makes a very good or ineffectual superficial SLA:

Good SLA: Look for these features

  1. Clear and specific: A good SLA clearly defines both parties' services, performance metrics, and expectations.
  2. Measurable metrics establish measurable and relevant Key Performance Indicators (KPIs) to assess the quality of services.
  3. Realistic targets: The SLA sets achievable service level targets that align with industry standards and the provider's capabilities.
  4. Monitoring and reporting: It includes provisions for regular monitoring, reporting, and performance review against the agreed-upon metrics.
  5. Remedies and penalties: The SLA outlines the consequences if the service provider fails to meet the agreed-upon service levels, such as financial penalties, service credits, or the right to terminate the contract.
  6. Flexibility: It allows for adjustments as the client's needs or circumstances change, including provisions for updating performance metrics or targets.

What are some warning signs of a "Bad" SLA: Avoid these hurdles:

  • Vague or ambiguous: A bad SLA lacks clarity in defining the scope of services, performance metrics, and expectations, leading to misunderstandings and disputes.
  • Immeasurable or irrelevant metrics: It fails to provide clear, measurable KPIs or includes metrics irrelevant to the client's needs.
  • Unrealistic targets: The SLA sets unattainable or overly optimistic service level targets that the provider is unlikely to achieve.
  • Insufficient monitoring and reporting: It lacks provisions for regular performance monitoring, reporting, or review, making it difficult to hold the provider accountable.
  • Weak remedies and penalties: The SLA does not specify meaningful consequences for failing to meet service levels or provides only weak incentives for the provider to improve performance.
  • Rigidity: It does not allow for flexibility or adjustments as the client's needs or circumstances change, potentially leading to suboptimal service or unnecessary costs.

Then there are those companies that strive to provide an "Excellent" SLA:

  1. Customized to the client's needs: An excellent SLA is tailored to the specific needs and objectives of the client, ensuring that the services provided are highly relevant and valuable.
  2. Comprehensive metrics and targets: Include a wide range of performance metrics and targets covering all critical service aspects, ensuring high accountability.
  3. Proactive improvement: The SLA encourages continuous improvement through regular performance reviews, feedback, and adjustment of targets or metrics as needed.
  4. Strong remedies and penalties: It specifies significant consequences for failing to meet service levels, creating a strong incentive for the provider to maintain a high level of performance.

Very bad SLA: these are the real troublemakers!!

  1. Unenforceable or unverifiable: An "evil" SLA includes terms that are difficult or impossible to enforce, such as metrics that cannot be measured or verified, rendering the agreement essentially meaningless.
  2. Overly complex or confusing - or conversely lacking detail / containing company marketing or over-inflated expertise or real-world traction: It contains overly complicated language or convoluted provisions that make it difficult for the client to understand their rights and obligations or to hold the provider accountable.
  3. Lacking in critical areas- too simplistic: The SLA omits essential provisions, such as data security, privacy, or dispute resolution, potentially exposing the client to significant risks. Similarly, it may be lacking critical detail/or could contain self-aggrandizing company marketing or over-inflated expertise or real-world traction

An evil SLA is vague, ambiguous, unenforceable, or lacking in critical areas.** (Have you seen one of these, unfortunately - we have!)

Conversely, a desirable service level agreement SLA is clear, specific, measurable, and tailored to the client's needs, with realistic targets, powerful remedies, and provisions for flexibility and continuous improvement.

Read More